The long struggle for power had ended, and the Asmonæan family was virtually
destroyed. Their sway had lasted about 130 years.
Looking back on the rapid rise and decline of the Maccabees, on their speedy
degeneration, on the deeds of cruelty with which their history soon became stained, on
the selfishness and reckless ambition which characterized them, and especially on the
profoundly anti-nationalist and anti-Pharisaic, we had almost said anti-Jewish, tendency
which marked their sway, we can understand the bitter hatred with which Jewish tradition
had followed their memory. The mention of them is of the scantiest. No universal
acclamation glor ifies even the deeds of Judas the Maccabee; no Talmudic tractate is
devoted to that 'feast of the dedication' which celebrated the purging of the Temple and
the restoration of Jewish worship. In fact such was the feeling, that the priestly course of
Joiarib - to which the Asmonæans belonged - is said to have been on service when the
first and the second Temple were destroyed, because 'guilt was to be punished on the
guilty.' More than that, 'R. Levi saith: Yehoyaribh ["Jehovah will contend"], the man [the
name of the man or family]; Meron ["rebellion," evidently a play upon Modin, the
birthplace of the Maccabees], the town; Mesarbey ["the rebels," evidently a play upon
Makkabey] - (masar beitha) He hath given up the Temple to the enemies.' Rabbi
Berachjah sa ith: 'Yah heribh [Jehoiarib], God contended with His children, because they
revolted and rebelled against Him' (Jer. Taan. iv. 8, p. 68 d, line 35 from bottom).43
Indeed, the opprobrious designation of rebellion, and Sarbaney El, rebels against God,
became in course of time so identified with the Maccabees. that it was used when its
meaning was no longer understood. Thus Origen (Euseb. Hist. Eccl. vi. 25) speaks of the
(Apocryphal) books of the Maccabees as 'inscribed Sarbeth Sarbane El'
(=τβρσ λ) ψνβρσ ), the disobedience, or rebellion (resistance) of the disobedient, or
rebels, against God.44 So thoroughly had these terms become identified in popular
parlance, that even the tyranny and cruelty of a Herod could not procure a milder
judgment on the sway of the Asmonæans.
43. Comp. Geiger, Urschrift, p. 204; Derenbourg , p. 119, note.
44. Comp. Geiger, u. s. p. 205, Note, Hamburger, u. s. p. 367. Various strange and most
unsatisfactory explanations have been proposed of these mysterious words, which yet, on
cons ideration, seem so easy of understanding. Comp. the curious explanations of Grimm,
Ewald, and others, in Grimm's Exeget. hand. zu d. Apokryphen, 3te Lief. p. xvii.
Derenbourg (Hist. de la Palest. pp. 450 -452) regards σαρβηδas a corruption for
σαφαρβηδ, and would render the whole by 'Book of the family of the Chief (ρ#) of the
people of God.'
The Life and Times of Jesus the Messiah
Alfred Edersheim
1883