margin, while Alford cites John's usage and gives grammatical reasons
for retaining the Authorized Version rendering. Webster and
Wilkinson comment is:
`Many of the ancient commentators place the period at hen (one),
thus reading, ho gegonen en hauto zoe en - "Whatever hath come
into being derives its origin and existence from Him"`.
Whatever punctuation we may at length accept, the meaning of the
apostle remains unchanged. Just as Paul could say that `in Him we
live, and move, and have our being', so John reveals, that in Him, Who
was the Word, and Who at the incarnation was made known as the
Only-begotten of the Father, was life. And then, transferring his
thought from the physical realm to the spiritual, he translates `life' into
terms of `light' and says `The life was the light of men'.
Just as God divided the light from the darkness, so we read:
`And the light shineth in darkness; and the darkness comprehended
it not' (1:5).
The word `comprehend' here is a translation of katalambano, from
kata, an intensive, and lambano, `to take'. In the middle voice, it is
rightly translated `comprehend', as in Ephesians 3:18; but where it
occurs in the active or passive, its meaning is `to grasp', `to seize', `to
overtake'. So, in John 8:3,4: `taken in adultery', or in 12:35: `lest
darkness come upon you'.
And in 1 Thessalonians 5:4: `but ye, brethren, are not in darkness,
that that day should overtake you as a thief'.
Some read John 1:5 as though the thought were that the darkness
did not `overpower' or `hold down' the light. The primary meaning `to
grasp', however, seems to be the most fitting here, `the darkness did
not grasp it'. Physical darkness is dispersed immediately the light
shines, but spiritual and mental darkness is more like a dense fog, that
remains obscure and dark even though the light of the sun be actually
shining. That this is the writer's meaning seems clear from verse 11,
`He came unto His own, and His own received (paralambano) Him
not'.
The sudden transition to the ministry of John the Baptist in verse 6
shows that John is not concerned with the question of the physical
realm of life and light, but is using the analogy of creation to enforce